Both women and men are finding themselves too guarded to commit. Credit: Unsplash/Gabriel Ogulu

Love used to be the dream for many young Black women … the vision of two people building something lasting in a world that often worked against them. But somewhere between the DMs, the dating apps, and the endless scrolling, something shifted. Now, more young Black women are questioning whether commitment is even worth the heartache.

A recent poll confirms what many have been whispering: More than half of young women, and nearly half of young men, believe infidelity is “very common.” Translation — the idea of loyalty is on life support.

The numbers don’t lie

The poll highlights a telling gender gap. Women are significantly more likely to assume cheating happens regularly, while men tend to downplay it. That difference in perception isn’t just about trust; it’s about experience. Many young women have grown tired of investing emotionally in relationships that feel transactional. The data tracks with national trends showing marriage rates at historic lows and cohabitation rates on the rise, particularly among Black millennials and Gen Z.

The culture shift

The modern dating world is a far cry from what our parents or grandparents knew. Hookup culture, boosted by social media and dating apps, has rewritten the rules. “Situationships,” those ambiguous, commitment-lite connections, have become the norm. Platforms designed for convenience have blurred boundaries, making it easier than ever to cheat or at least flirt with the idea of it.

Instagram and TikTok have turned validation into currency and love into a form of content. When everyone’s “talking stage” is public, it’s hard to build something private and real. Add in the loneliness and isolation many experienced during the pandemic, and what’s left is a generation craving intimacy — but too skeptical to believe it’s possible.

The gender gap

Young Black women, in particular, are feeling the weight of this shift. They’ve been asked to carry emotional labor, to heal partners who are still finding themselves, and to make peace with inconsistent effort in the name of “independence.” The message often given to them is that they should be strong, self-sufficient, and unbothered, leaving little room for vulnerability or hope.

Meanwhile, men are navigating their own changing roles, often caught between traditional expectations and new realities of equality and accountability. But as women’s standards rise, trust has eroded. The result: a dating pool full of people too guarded to truly connect.

The fallout

Black women haven’t completely given up on love. Many are just raising their standards. Credit: Unsplash/KadariusSeegars

This disillusionment isn’t just about romance — it’s reshaping the very fabric of community. Declining marriage rates and rising single-parent households are more than statistics; they reflect a broader loss of faith in partnership as a pathway to stability.

For generations, love, in all its imperfect glory,  helped anchor Black families through struggle. Now, that foundation feels shaky. When love becomes optional or disposable, we lose more than connection. We lose continuity, culture, and, sometimes, ourselves.

A way forward

So, is love dead? Not quite. But it is on life support, and revival requires intention. Healing the relationship gap means doing the hard work — therapy, self-awareness, and unlearning the toxic norms that have made distrust seem normal.

Transparency is the new romance. Therapy is the new love language. Faith, whether spiritual or personal, is the resuscitation we need.

The truth is, young Black women aren’t giving up on love. They’re demanding a version that fully honors them. And maybe that’s not the death of love — maybe it’s its rebirth.

I’m a Houstonian (by way of Smackover, Arkansas). My most important job is being a wife to my amazing husband, mother to my three children, and daughter to my loving mother. I am the National Bestselling...