This article was originally written by Joseph Williams for Word In Black.
A month after a Black teenager vanished during a boating trip to a Mississippi barrier island with his white friends, officials have arrested three people, subpoenas have been issued, and his body has undergone two autopsies.
But there is still no answer to the question that started it all: What happened to Nolan Wells?
LEARN MORE: More Unanswered Questions Fuel Doubts In Nolan Wells’ Death
At least three people have been arrested on federal charges connected to the case, but none is accused of having anything to do with Wells’ death. Instead, they are accused of making threats against public officials or people connected to the investigation, an extraordinary turn in a case already fueled by national attention and rampant social-media speculation.
Meanwhile, Mississippi has completed its official autopsy, but the findings remain under wraps.
Angel Myers McIlrath, the local district attorney, says the case, including the autopsy findings, will be presented to a grand jury once investigators finish their work. Experts say it’s standard procedure in the county for unnatural deaths, not necessarily an indication that prosecutors believe a crime occurred.
But it leaves Wells’ parents roughly where they were when their son was found dead on July 6: waiting for someone to tell them how he died.
Private investigation
Civil rights attorney Ben Crump, who represents the family, isn’t waiting quietly. His legal team is conducting its own investigation and has taken steps that could lay the groundwork for litigation, including sending evidence-preservation notices to people connected to Wells’ final hours. An attorney working with Crump has also sought subpoenas for records from Snapchat, Life360, and other companies that could help reconstruct Wells’ movements before he died.
The investigation into Nolan Wells’ death now reaches far beyond Mississippi, drawing national attention and legal action. Yet after two autopsies and weeks of scrutiny, no official explanation has emerged.
The unanswered questions have turned Wells’ death from a Mississippi tragedy into a national cause.
Wells, an incoming college freshman and former high school football player, traveled to Horn Island, a remote state park off the Mississippi coast that’s popular with young people, on July 4 with friends. He never returned home.
After Wells’ mother reported him missing, the teenager’s body was recovered two days later from the northwestern part of the island. Authorities initially said they had no evidence of foul play, but Wells’ parents questioned conflicting accounts among his friends about why their son apparently remained behind while the rest of them headed back to port aboard their crippled boat.
Autopsy inconclusive
The Rev. Al Sharpton, who delivered the eulogy at Wells’ funeral, has joined the family’s demand for answers. Filmmaker Tyler Perry helped pay the funeral expenses, while former NFL quarterback Colin Kaepernick paid for an independent autopsy. Television crime personality Nancy Grace has devoted episodes of her program to the case.
That second autopsy, however, didn’t settle anything.
Dr. Roger Mitchell Jr., the former chief medical examiner for Washington, D.C., classified both Wells’ cause and manner of death as “undetermined pending investigation.” He found no fractures or deep-tissue injuries but noted an area of discoloration on the back of Wells’ head that he could not conclusively explain.
Because portions of the airway and other tissue had been removed during the state’s examination — a routine part of an autopsy — Mitchell also could not independently determine whether Wells drowned. Mitchell said he could not rule out non-accidental factors, but also could not conclude whether Wells had been killed.
Evidence or speculation?
That distinction has become increasingly important as the case has exploded online.
Perhaps no piece of evidence illustrates that better than a recorded July 4 call to Sea Tow, a private marine towing company. Mississippi authorities released audio of the call, made at about 4 p.m. by someone aboard the boat Wells had traveled on after it ran into trouble near Horn Island.
Social-media users began dissecting faint voices in the background. An audio engineer produced an enhanced version that went viral, with some listeners saying they heard phrases such as “Is he dead?” and references to Wells.
But what people think they hear on social media isn’t necessarily evidence.
A forensic audio expert interviewed by People cautioned that enhancement can introduce artifacts and that suggestion can affect what listeners believe they hear. A reliable forensic examination, she said, would require the original, uncompressed recording and a documented process. Crump says his team has hired experts to analyze the call.
Death threats investigated
Meanwhile, the speculation has produced real-world consequences.
Federal authorities have charged people from California, Ohio, and Illinois with allegedly making threats connected to the case. The targets have included government offices, a Mississippi judge whose son was among Wells’ friends, and witnesses connected to the investigation. One man allegedly sent a witness the person’s home address while threatening to kill the witness and family members.
Yet none of those arrests shed light on what happened to Wells.
RELATED: Another Mysterious Death Strikes a Nerve
His mother, Christine Wonsley, has said from the beginning that she isn’t asking authorities to confirm a conspiracy or reach a predetermined conclusion. She wants what any parent would want after a child leaves home for a holiday outing and ends up dead.
“We just want honesty and transparency,” Wonsley told ABC’s “Good Morning America” shortly after her son’s death. “We want a thorough investigation.”
A month later, that investigation has generated federal charges, forensic examinations, subpoenas, celebrity involvement, and countless hours of amateur detective work online.
What it still hasn’t produced is an answer.