Residents of the Fifth Ward and Kashmere Gardens are demanding an EPA report on contamination and health risks in their neighborhoods. Credit: Tannistha Sinha/Defender

Pamela Matthews remembers playing in the rainbow-colored water that pooled near the railroad yard in Houston’s Fifth Ward. Whenever it rained, the water shimmered with an oily sheen. She and the other neighborhood children splashed through it, unaware of what might be lurking beneath the surface.

“We played in that water,” Matthews, 65, recalled. “We were just children. We didn’t know.”

Decades later, Matthews is a two-time ovarian cancer survivor who has buried family members and watched childhood friends die from various cancers. Her mother died of pancreatic cancer just a week after her diagnosis. Her brother battled multiple cancers. Others she grew up with died of leukemia and lung cancer.

Now, Matthews and other residents of Fifth Ward and Kashmere Gardens want answers about the contamination that has plagued their predominantly Black neighborhoods for decades.

“EPA has posted soil results, but numbers on a page don’t tell a mother whether her backyard is safe.”

Christian Menefee, Congressman, 18th Congressional District

But those answers remain tied up in a federal health risk evaluation that residents say has been sitting with the Environmental Protection Agency for nearly 400 days.

A 400-day wait for answers

Residents and U.S. Rep. Christian Menefee are demanding the release of the health risk evaluation examining contamination at the Union Pacific rail yard and former Houston Wood Preserving Works site.

The EPA has had the report since Oct. 9, 2025, according to community advocates. Menefee, who represents Texas’ 18th Congressional District, has warned that if the agency fails to respond by Dec. 1, he will “use every tool available to him in the next Congress.”

For families who have spent years burying loved ones and worrying about their own health, the report could provide critical information about potential exposure risks and what should happen next.

“Families in Fifth Ward and Kashmere Gardens have watched their neighbors get cancer for years,” said Menefee, who represents the 18th Congressional District. “The goal was to find out what’s in the ground and what it means. It tells people what the testing means for their health and what remediation should be taken. EPA has posted soil results, but numbers on a page don’t tell a mother whether her backyard is safe.”

The cancer cluster community was told to expect the draft report in early 2026. But it has not yet come.

In response to the delay, Menefee wrote a letter to EPA administrators Lee Zeldin and Scott Mason IV demanding the immediate release of the report and a firm timeline for its completion, following a 60-day public comment period.

https://menefee.house.gov/sites/evo-subsites/menefee.house.gov/files/evo-media-document/epa-letter-rep.menefee-11.19.26.pdf 

400 days of waiting

Community members in the historically Black neighborhood have waited nearly 400 days for the report.

“The document that matters is the health risk evaluation,” Menefee said. “It tells people what the testing means for their health and what remediation should be taken.”

Menefee laid out his demands for the EPA. He wants the agency to release the report, open a 60-day public comment period, and adopt a plan proposed by the community advisory group.

“My message to the EPA is: Do your job,” Menefee said. “Fulfill your promises.”

Regional EPA officials did not respond to the Defender’s request for comment.

When contamination was found at the nearby Hester House community center, Matthews said officials roped off the area. Her own family was told they were not eligible for testing. 

“They said we weren’t eligible for testing; we’re eligible to die,” Matthews said. “What kind of hope does that give families that were here, that spent their lives getting a place that they figured was safe?” 

Wiping away tears, she demanded answers about the health risks that still loom large in her neighborhood.

Her family’s property represents generations of work and financial sacrifice. Matthews believes the report would allow her to find closure about her family members and help those battling cancer.

“It [the report] would let me know what we’re dealing with because some of us don’t have the means to move,” Matthews said. “We put all of our funds into the place that we have, keeping it up and paying taxes.”

Community members said this was intentional

Joetta Stevenson, who chairs the EPA’s Community Advisory Group and is president of the Greater Fifth Ward Super Neighborhood, said residents have kept up their end.

Every month, the group meets with EPA staff who fly in from out of town.

The group met monthly with EPA staff who fly in from out of town. But the meetings stopped once the pressure to provide the report built up.

“At the end of September, we got wind that the report won’t be ready until the end of the year,” Stevenson said. “The specialists that they had been bringing in; they weren’t bringing them in anymore. We were having one-off conversations with them rather than group conversations, and nobody had answers to any of the questions we posed…So people need to remember, this data is the key to unlocking things. It’s not as though we made this up.”

Adding that the field sampling was completed in December 2024 and that analysis and write-up should have taken only a few months, Stevenson said the agency was already working on the project before the change in administration.

“We played in that water. We were just children. We didn’t know.”

Pamela Matthews, Fifth Ward resident and two-time cancer survivor

Union Pacific says it submitted its risk assessment to the EPA in October 2025 and a revised version in April 2026, at the agency’s request. 

“Union Pacific has worked closely and cooperatively with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency since the agency agreed to oversee expanded environmental testing at the former wood preserving works site,” said spokesperson Robynn Tysver.

Meanwhile, Stevenson wants the draft in public hands, even if it is unfinished. The community has experts who work with it for free, she said, from Texas Southern University and the Environmental Defense Fund. 

“Give us that report so we can look at it, the public can look at it and do commentary about it,” Stevenson said.

Anger, grief, bills no one steps in to pay

Sandra Edwards, of Impact Fifth Ward Justice, has lived on a dead-end street, describing it as one where the “whole street died from cancer.” 

Edwards said that members of the group are losing people while they wait.

“Give us the information,” she said, addressing the EPA. “We need to proceed. We need to know what our future looks like…We are tired.”

Residents had fruit trees and garden produce tested privately and were told not to eat what they grew, said Katherine Blueford-Daniels.

“We’ve got to be taken seriously,” Blueford-Daniels added. “We’ve been doing this a long, long time. I don’t know if they’re waiting for us to die off, but even with that, we still have young soldiers that are still willing to pick up the bad mantle and carry the baton.”

Mary Hutchins, who has lived in the area for 60 years, has had and survived cancer twice.

“Give us that report so we can look at it, the public can look at it and do commentary about it.”

Joetta Stevenson, chair of the EPA’s Community Advisory Group

In an interview with the Defender, she said every house on the street at Liberty and Lavender in the Kashmere Gardens neighborhood has had a brush with cancer.

“And most of them passed,” Hutchins said.

Even with insurance, she added, each chemotherapy treatment cost her about $500 out of pocket, and she still gets scans once or twice a year.

In a post-midterm blue Texas, she wants support with health care to prevent cancer recurrences.

What happens next?

Menefee says a new Congress in January gives him more leverage and has said he will use “every single tool in my power.”

For residents, the unanswered questions now concern both environmental risk and government transparency.

Stevenson said the community needs data to make safer decisions.

“We’re looking for the root cause so that we can understand what we can do for preventative measures,” Stevenson said. “We can make good decisions to keep each other safe.”

I cover education, housing, and politics in Houston for the Houston Defender Network as a Report for America corps member. I graduated with a master of science in journalism from the University of Southern...