Houston council members were seeking to put restrictions on HPD’s cooperation with ICE into city law. Credit: Tannistha Sinha/Defender

Attorney General Ken Paxton, who lost the midterm election race to Nathan Johnson, is renewing his lawsuit against Houston City officials after Houston Mayor John Whitmire issued an executive order limiting the Houston Police Department’s interactions with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officers. 

Weeks after Democrats swept statewide elections in Texas, Whitmire’s announcement was followed by a proposition put forth by three council members, Alejandra Salinas, Tiffany Thomas, and Edward Pollard.

They proposed codifying the directive into law to secure protections beyond Whitmire’s mayoralty. But the ordinance, which would make Houston’s ICE restrictions permanent, will not be voted on. Council members who backed the ordinance are now pushing back.

City attorney Arturo Michel said the ordinance would be “unlawful” and would violate Senate Bill 4, a 2017 state law that mandates local cooperation with ICE.

“The mayor took the executive order after he had spoken with the new leadership because he had the sense that they would not enforce SB 4, and he’s been right so far that hasn’t happened,” Michel told the Defender. “The best outcome here is to have the state permanently determined not to enforce it and even better to amend SB 4.”

Michel believes the state would have to remove provisions of SB 4 in the new legislative session for the ordinance to be considered legal.

The latest proposal would have gone further by incorporating restrictions from Whitmire’s November executive order directly into city law.

While Whitmire said he does oppose the ordinance, he called it “unnecessary.”

Council members push back

Council members Salinas, Thomas, and Pollard said that their proposition mirrored the language of Whitmire’s executive order and would codify it into law.

Yet, Michel determined that the council cannot bring the ordinance to a vote.

“Houstonians have spoken and are clear. They want to end HPD’s involvement with ICE. Houston’s Charter gives Council clear authority to ‘prescribe, by ordinance, rules and regulations governing the operation of each department,’” Council members Salinas, Thomas, and Pollard said in a joint statement. “The legal department has repeatedly affirmed this, determining Council could prohibit HPD traffic stop quotas and bar officers from prolonging traffic stops solely for an ICE administrative warrant…The City Attorney’s role is to advise, not stonewall Council’s authority.”

“City Council passed these protections once before, and now we have another opportunity to get this right.”

Council members Alejandra Salinas, Tiffany Thomas and Edward Pollard,
in a joint statement

What the ordinance wanted to do

The new proposal built on an immigration ordinance spearheaded by Salinas and approved by Houston City Council in April. The ordinance addressed prolonged detentions during traffic stops, ending HPD’s previous practice of waiting up to 30 minutes in certain cases involving ICE administrative warrants.

The council had to pass a revised version of the city’s immigration ordinance following threats from Gov. Greg Abbott to pull $114 million in public safety funding if the changes were not approved.

In the new ordinance, Salinas, Pollard, and Thomas proposed reducing HPD’s cooperation with ICE. This includes an immediate stop on police officers who prolong traffic stops, detain someone, or contact ICE solely for a civil administrative warrant unless there is a justifiable criminal offense.

They also demand a quarterly transparency report from HPD and ICE that includes the reason for each jail booking and whether ICE was contacted about a victim or suspect.

Whitmire’s executive order and the ordinance follow the death of Lorenzo Salgado at the hands of an ICE officer who shot the Mexican national. Salgado had been in the United States for decades and was driving his construction crew to a job site when the officer killed him.

“The killing of Lorenzo Salgado Araujo and the serious injuries Miguel Parra-Hernandez suffered at the hands of ICE underscore the urgency. City Council passed these protections once before, and now we have another opportunity to get this right,” the council members said in a joint statement.

Houston Mayor John Whitmire issued an executive order limiting HPD’s cooperation with ICE. Credit: City of Houston

What did the mayor say?

“The city attorney ruled that it’s unlawful and conflicts with state law,” Whitmire told the Defender. “There’s nothing broken. We have a very effective HPD policy that goes after the worst of the worst…we need to let the legislature address the issue. Let Congress deal with it.”

Calling it a “legislative process” in which not everyone “gets their way,” Whitmire foresees a hearing on SB 4 at which Houston City Council Members can testify.

“I’m doing what I think was in the best interest of the city,” Whitmire said. “My executive order said HPD carries out state and city ordinances and laws. We will not contact ICE based on the new leadership in Austin. HPD will only contact ICE if you commit a new offense, the worst of the worst.”

How does the ordinance impact Black Houstonians?

Immigration enforcement affects a substantial Black immigrant community population.

The Black immigrant population in the country reached 4.7 million in 2024, growing faster than the overall foreign-born population, according to the Migration Policy Institute.

The Houston-The Woodlands-Sugar Land metropolitan area had approximately 128,000 Black immigrants, representing 10% of its Black population, according to the institute’s analysis of 2020-24 census data.

In 2020-24, nearly 2.1 million Black immigrants were African-born, with the top five countries of origin being Jamaica, Haiti, Nigeria, Ethiopia, and Ghana.

The experiences of Black immigration can be “overlooked,” especially when discussed through the lens of other racial groups, according to the Migration Policy Institute.

I cover education, housing, and politics in Houston for the Houston Defender Network as a Report for America corps member. I graduated with a master of science in journalism from the University of Southern...