Studio shot of a fashionable woman taking a selfie against a orange background

Have you scrolled through Instagram or TikTok, minding your business, when an influencer talks about the best product theyโ€™ve ever used? 

Maybe itโ€™s a skincare line that will โ€œerase hyperpigmentation overnightโ€ or a waist trainer that will โ€œsnatch your waist in days with no effort.โ€ They look good, the packaging is cute, and the influencer swears theyโ€™ve seen results. So, we tap the link in their bio, add to the cart, and spend our hard-earned money, expecting magic.

Then reality hits. The skincare product burns your face. The waist trainer is cheap and uncomfortable. And that influencer? Theyโ€™ve already moved on to the next brand deal, never addressing the fact that they sold you a dream that never came true.

When influence doesnโ€™t equal expertise

Social media has made it way too easy for people to pose as experts. Just because someone has a large following doesnโ€™t mean they know what theyโ€™re talking about. Yet, influencers constantly push financial advice, health tips, and quick solutions, even with no credentials or real experience in those fields.

Kier Gaines, a popular licensed therapist known for this wholesome content on family and marriage, shared three ideas that people need to consider before taking advice from social media, which I happen to agree with. 

  1. Who are you? Where is the evidence that youโ€™ve implemented the strategies that youโ€™re selling to your audience? 
  2. What is your credential? Whatโ€™s your experience? Are you formally educated?
  3. Where are the actionable steps?
Influence is how someone reacts to your status. Expertise is how someone reacts to your knowledge. Credit: Getty Images

The UNESCO study found that 62% of artists asked indicated they don’t check content for veracity before disseminating it to their audience. About one-third of influencers admitted to sharing material without verifying its accuracy if it came from a reliable source, while 37% admitted to confirming information with a fact-checking website before sharing it.

UNESCO warned that โ€œthe low prevalence of fact-checking highlights their vulnerability to misinformation, which can have far-reaching consequences for public discourse and trust in media.โ€

According to Nielsen Scarborough, Black adults are 71% more likely than the general population to buy products endorsed by an influencer.

Be a smart follower

This doesnโ€™t mean all influencers are bad. Some genuinely want to introduce people to good products and opportunities. But if an influencer constantly promotes sponsored content, never discusses a product’s downsides, or only hypes things when thereโ€™s a check involved, itโ€™s a red flag.

Influencers are great at selling dreams, but that doesnโ€™t mean we must buy into them. At the end of the day, the real flex is knowing when to call out the cap.

I cover Houston's education system as it relates to the Black community for the Defender as a Report for America corps member. I'm a multimedia journalist and have reported on social, cultural, lifestyle,...